
Right.
So trying to cook, let alone veganize, my Gran's recipes is...difficult. For one thing, her recipes are pretty stark when it comes to instructions. Generally, what you'll see is a list of ingredients, a temperature, and a time. Luckily, I grew up in the same house with her. When it was Christmas cookie baking time, I'd be in the kitchen watching her every move until she got tired of me and sent me to the kitchen table to mold my very own pile of dough. I absorbed enough by watching her to be able to figure out how to make the cookies.
But then, my English Gran's English is not necessarily my English. I'll usually have to call her when I come across a line that reads "2 - 3 oz. cream cheese." I'll call and ask, "Gran, does that mean between two and three ounces of cream cheese, or two three ounce portions of cream cheese? And how did you measure these portions, since cream cheese usually comes in half-pint containers?" And she'll respond with something like, "just use a half a pint of sour cream," leaving me, of course, completely flumoxed.
Last year, when I made my favorite almond tarts for the first time, I had the recipe for the dough written down, called her with the above question, was told to use her butter tart dough recipe instead. She then read said butter tart dough recipe to me, which was completely different than the butter tart dough recipe that she'd written down for me.
The way that I know we're related, of course, is that I wrote down the following:
4 cups flour
Pinch salt
1 lb. oleo
1/2 pint sour cream
However, what I think she said, and what I'm pretty sure that I used, was 1/2 pint cream cheese for the sour cream. We're messes, the both of us.
Veganizing the dough was a snap. I used a soy margarine that I discovered recently called Willow's Creek. Yes, there are hydrogenated oils in it. No, I don't care. Why, you ask? Because the WC margarine is, like, half the cost of Earth Balance Buttery Sticks, and when you make 1,000-2,000 Christmas cookies each year, the cost of all that EB will ruin me. And, has anyone else noticed that EB has a funky smell to it when cooked? The hubster tells me that I'm crazy, but seriously, I smell it, and it grosses me out.
I also subbed Tofutti Better than Cream Cheese for the cream cheese. Yes, the stuff is expensive. However, the one recipe of dough will yield at least six dozen tarts (I'm still not done using it all), so one or two tubs of the stuff each year won't bankrupt anyone. Maybe.
Veganizing the filling, however, is another story. The ingredients, and this is from memory, are something like:
3/4 cup ground almonds
1 cup confectioners' sugar
2 eggs
1/4 cup almond extract
2 drops green food coloring
I vaguely remembered an on-going cookie baking competition at Herbivore where the competitors would use the same cookie recipe, each use a different egg replacer, and then judge the results. I also vaguely remembered that the guy who used soy yogurt usually had the best results, so soy yogurt I used.
The results were not so good.
For one thing, the cookies did not taste almond-ey at all. I'm not sure if the yogurt overpowered the almond taste or what, but though the smell of the cookies baking was right on, the taste was not. For another, I cooked them for 30 minutes at 350 rather than 20 minutes, because the filling just wouldn't set. I eventually took them out of the oven just to keep the shells from getting too overdone.
Also, the things didn't rise, and the longer they cooled, the more they sunk in the middle. The taste wasn't terrible, but the insides were way too gooey. Not to mention, the poor things were just too ugly to frost (I use confectioners' sugar, soy half and half, vanilla extract to ice them and then top them with half of a candied cherry or two shelled pistachios). The hubster and I ate them, of course, but soy yogurt is definitely not the answer for these puppies.
Tonight, I think I'll try using soy milk curdled with apple cider vinegar and a little bit of baking powder to get the things to rise up a bit. I'll also add a little bit of almond extract to get the taste right. For now, some pictures of my first attempt.